top of page

INCOME PROTECTION vs UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE

Writer: Bridget Morrow
Bridget Morrow
Nov 10
6 min read

Let's talk about something that doesn't get nearly enough attention when it comes to protecting your finances: income protection.


Imagine insuring your car but not the wheels. We insure our devices, our pets, and quite rightly our homes. But often overlooked is the income that makes everything else possible.


Your ability to earn a living is arguably one of your biggest financial assets. Without it, keeping up with the mortgage, paying the bills, buying the weekly food shop and maintaining the lifestyle you've worked hard to build can suddenly become a whole lot more difficult.


And yet, Income Protection is one of the most underrated types of personal insurance. It's not particularly glamorous. There's no shiny new kitchen or exciting holiday at the end of it. In fact, it's the sort of insurance you hope you'll never need.


But if illness or injury stopped you working for months, or even years, it could be one of the most valuable policies you ever take out.


So, let's look at what Income Protection actually does, how it compares with Accident, Sickness and Unemployment (ASU) cover, and why understanding the difference matters.


First things first: What is Income Protection?

Traditional Income Protection is designed to replace a proportion of your earnings if you're unable to work because of illness or injury. Think of it as your own private sick pay. If you became seriously unwell, had an accident or developed a condition that prevented you from working, your policy could pay you a regular monthly income to help keep your finances ticking over.


And importantly, it isn't just about your mortgage. It's about everything else that comes with everyday life:

  • Your mortgage or rent.

  • Household bills and utilities.

  • Food and shopping.

  • Car payments and running costs.

  • Children's clubs, activities and school expenses.

  • All those little monthly payments that somehow add up to a small fortune!


Depending on the policy you choose, Income Protection can pay out for a relatively short period or potentially continue until your chosen retirement age. That longer-term protection is what makes it particularly valuable.


So, what is Accident, Sickness and Unemployment (ASU) insurance?

ASU cover does something slightly different. Mortgage Protection is designed to help with your financial commitments if you experience an accident, sickness or involuntary unemployment.


Essentially, it provides a monthly benefit if you meet the policy's conditions for making a claim.

You can choose how much monthly cover you need, and whether you want accident and sickness cover, unemployment cover or a combination.


It's particularly useful if you're worried about losing your job as well as being unable to work through illness or injury.


However, there is an important difference: ASU is designed to provide short-term financial support, rather than replace your income indefinitely. Mortgage Protection offers benefit periods of 12 or 24 months, depending on the option selected.


And that's where things start to get interesting.


Income Protection vs ASU: What are the differences?

Although they might sound similar, they offer quite different levels of protection.


1. How long will the payments last?

This is probably the biggest difference. With ASU, payments are limited to the benefit period you've selected, typically 12 or 24 months per claim. With traditional Income Protection, you can choose full-term cover, which could continue paying out until you recover, return to work or reach the end of your policy term, subject to the policy conditions. Some Income Protection policies also offer shorter 12- or 24-month benefit options, which can make them more affordable.


How it works irl?


Imagine being diagnosed with a condition that meant you couldn't work for three years. With a 24-month ASU policy, your payments would stop after two years. With a full-term Income Protection policy, you could potentially continue receiving your monthly benefit for the entire period you're eligible to claim. That's a pretty significant difference when you're facing a long-term illness.


2. What happens if you lose your job?

Here's where ASU has an advantage. It can include unemployment protection, meaning you may be able to claim if you're made involuntarily redundant, subject to the policy's eligibility requirements and exclusions.

Traditional Income Protection generally doesn't cover redundancy. It is designed to protect against illness and injury, not a change in your employment circumstances. So, if redundancy is a particular concern, ASU may offer something that traditional Income Protection doesn't.


3. How much money will you receive?

With Income Protection, the insurer generally calculates your maximum benefit based on your earnings and the amount of cover you've selected. The aim is to replace a proportion of your lost income, rather than necessarily cover every penny.


With Mortgage Protection, you select a monthly benefit to help cover your mortgage payments and potentially certain additional household expenses, within the policy limits.


The important distinction is that one is designed around replacing earnings, while the other is designed around helping meet specified financial commitments.


4. What happens if you return to work gradually?

Something people don't always consider is that returning to work isn't necessarily an overnight event. After a serious illness or injury, you might only be able to manage a few hours a day or return on reduced responsibilities.


Some traditional Income Protection policies include proportionate or partial benefit options. These can help top up your earnings if you return to work but aren't yet able to earn what you did before.

The exact benefits depend on the insurer and policy. This can be particularly valuable when recovery takes time and you need to ease yourself back into working life.


A real-life example: What if you couldn't work for three years?

Let's imagine you're earning £45,000 a year, have a mortgage, two children and all the usual household commitments. Unfortunately, you develop a serious health condition that prevents you from working for three years.


Here's how the two types of cover could differ.


With ASU:

You've selected a 24-month benefit period. Your policy pays an eligible monthly benefit while you're unable to work and meet the claim conditions. After 24 months, the payments stop. Unfortunately, you're still unable to work, and you've now got another 12 months to navigate without that insurance income.


With full-term Income Protection:

You've selected a policy designed to pay a monthly benefit until your chosen retirement age.

If your claim continues to meet the policy conditions, your payments could continue throughout those three years. You have a longer-term financial safety net while you concentrate on getting better.


Of course, neither policy guarantees a claim payment. Both are subject to their definitions, exclusions, waiting periods and terms. But the difference in the length of protection could be life-changing.


Isn't Income Protection really expensive?

This is probably one of the biggest misconceptions. People sometimes assume that because Income Protection can pay out over a much longer period, the premiums must be eye-wateringly expensive.


But the cost depends on lots of factors, including:

  • Your age.

  • Your occupation.

  • Your health and medical history.

  • How much monthly benefit you want.

  • How long you want the policy to run.

  • Your chosen deferred period (how long you wait before payments start).


You can also tailor the policy around your circumstances. For example, if your employer provides six months of sick pay, you might choose a longer deferred period to reduce your premium.


If you're self-employed and have no employer sick pay to fall back on, you might want payments to start much sooner. It's about finding the right balance between the protection you need and what you can comfortably afford.


And remember, a cheaper policy isn't necessarily a better policy if it stops paying just when you need it most.


So, which one should you choose?

There isn't necessarily a right or wrong answer. It depends on what you're trying to protect.


Income Protection might be the better fit if:

  • Your household relies heavily on your earnings.

  • You have a mortgage and family commitments.

  • You want protection against long-term illness or injury.

  • You don't have substantial savings or generous employer sick pay.

  • You're self-employed and don't have access to company sick pay.

  • You want the reassurance of knowing your cover could continue beyond two years.


ASU might be worth considering if:

  • You're particularly concerned about redundancy.

  • You want short-term help with your mortgage commitments.

  • You want accident, sickness and unemployment protection.

  • You're comfortable with the fact that payments are time-limited.

And in some circumstances, people may benefit from considering both types of cover, depending on their needs and budget.


The most important thing to remember

We spend a lot of time protecting the things we've worked hard to buy. But perhaps we should spend just as much time protecting the thing that allows us to buy them in the first place.


Your income pays your mortgage. It puts food on the table. It funds family holidays, school shoes, birthday parties and all the little things that make life what it is.


If it disappeared tomorrow, how long could your savings keep everything going? A month? Three months? Six months? And what happens after that?


Income Protection might not be the most exciting thing you'll ever spend money on. But if life throws you a curveball, having the right cover in place could mean one less thing to worry about.


Because the last thing you need when you're trying to get better is to be worrying about how you're going to pay the bills.


Important information: This article is for general information and educational purposes only. Insurance products have different eligibility criteria, definitions, exclusions, deferred periods and benefit limits. The suitability of any policy depends on individual circumstances. Full policy terms and conditions should always be checked.


The information on this website is for use of residents of the United Kingdom only. No representations are made as to whether the information is applicable in any other country that may have access to it. 

Approved by The Openwork Partnership on 01/02/2026

Stakes Hill Financial Services

Romayne, Stakes Hill Road, Waterlooville, England, PO7 7BD jodene.Smith@justmortgages.co.uk

TEL: 07935 861489

​​​

Other offices include Wisbech, Cambridgeshire and Ash Vale, Surrey. 

  • alt.text.label.Facebook

Stakes Hill Financial Services is a trading name of Just Mortgages Direct Ltd, which is an appointed representative of The Openwork Partnership, a trading style of Openwork Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

 

Just Mortgages Direct Ltd registered office: Colwyn House, Sheepen Place, Colchester, Essex, CO3 3LD Registered in England & Wales No 2412345.

Stakes Hill FS logo

©2023 by Stakes Hill Financial Services

bottom of page